Relying on Fake German Strength

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Share on RedditPrint this pageEmail this to someone

While we’re sitting on the edge of our chairs, waiting breathlessly for the Greek election, or for Fate to swallow Greece and send financial Armageddon over the Eurozone, stock markets rallied. Not because of a sudden plethora of good economic news, but in anticipation of how central banks might react to the Greek vote—that’s how far this farce has come! As if sheer artificial liquidity could wash away the putrid odor of decomposing debt.

They lined up on Friday to give their spiel. ECB President Mario Draghi would “continue to supply liquidity to solvent banks where needed.” Bank of Japan governor Masaaki Shirakawa was “prepared to take all possible measures” but denied rumors that central banks around the globe would take coordinated action. The Bank of England spoke up. The Swiss National Bank confirmed its iron determination to keep the flood of euros at bay, with capital controls, if it had to; its currency peg would hold, come hell or high water.

To calm the credit markets, it was leaked earlier that Draghi, European Council President Herman van Rompuy, European Commission President José Manuel Barroso, and Euro Group President Jean-Claude Juncker were feverishly bent over a grand plan to convert the beleaguered monetary union into some sort of federal state governed by unelected EU bureaucrats.

So, while waiting for the vision to appear, I skyped with a friend in Germany who owns two restaurants. They’re doing well, he said. 2011 was a record year, and this year looks good too. He’d redecorated, his new menu was a hit, and he was excited, though it was a day-to-day struggle, in a jungle of regulations, with taxes out the wazoo. And what about the debt crisis? He didn’t pay much attention to it, he said.

Indeed. The debt crisis has been good to Germany, formerly the “sick man of Europe.” After Reunification, Germany was marked by high unemployment, stagnation, and lacking innovation. The dotcom euphoria bypassed it. Inflation surged and real wages declined. Industry restructured, ditched unprofitable operations, axed workers. But countries around it boomed. Spain and Greece were riding high. The Celtic Tiger was cleaning everyone’s clock. And Germans became morose. Eventually, the internal devaluation, insidious as it was for the middle class, paid off for industry. Exports took off, and Germany was showing signs of growth.

Then the financial crisis hit. Export orders fell off a cliff, causing GDP to plunge 2.1% in the fourth quarter of 2008 and a horrid 3.8% in the first quarter of 2009. Annualized, those two quarters printed a double-digit decline in GDP. The worst two quarters in the history of the Federal Republic. The German economy lives and dies by its exports.

But as the financial crisis morphed into the Eurozone debt crisis and began infecting the periphery, Germany recovered. Exports to Asia skyrocketed, exports to European countries did well, and a good part of the US stimulus money made its way to German enterprises, such as Siemens and its suppliers. They produced and hired. Exports last year exceeded €1 trillion for the first time ever. Unemployment dropped to a two-decade low. Its budget is nearly balanced, and yields on its debt probed zero. Euphoria set in.

Short lived, it seems. According to a slew of recent data, Germany is backsliding. Its banks are highly leveraged and packed with who knows what kinds of decomposing assets. Its debt, at 81% of GDP, is high for a country that can’t print its own money, and is higher than that of Spain. If China implodes and the US enters a recession, while the Eurozone continues to teeter, German exports will once again collapse. The savior of Europe will find itself in a deep recession, with large deficits, rising unemployment, spiking yields….

“Germany’s strength is not unlimited,” Chancellor Angela Merkel told the Bundestag on Thursday. She was committed to the euro, she said, but would eschew counterproductive quick fixes, such as Eurobonds and other forms of debt sharing. She was addressing President Obama, French President François Hollande, and her European counterparts who have been demanding that the German taxpayer pick up the tab for the profligacy of others.

The same day, the French government drove a wedge into the rift between the two countries, the core of the Eurozone. Without it, nothing will work. Hollande, while in Rome to form an anti-Merkel triumvirate with Italy and Spain, presented his plan to save the Eurozone: institute “euro-bills” (his word for Eurobonds) and use ECB funds to recapitalize banks (via the ESM).

Panic attack, it was called in Germany: the French mega banks, chock full with rotten assets, were teetering, and to avoid having to beg Germany to help bail them out, Hollande wanted to change the rules so that he could ask the ECB instead.

Then, Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault suggested that Merkel shouldn’t “sink into simplistic formulas.” And Arnaud Montebourg, Minister of Industrial Renewal, accused her of “ideological blindness.”

Friday, Merkel hit back. “Pooling the debt may be of interest to some, but in Germany, it would lead to mediocrity,” she said. “And mediocrity must not become the standard in the Eurozone”—thus slapping the M-word on the French.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Share on RedditPrint this pageEmail this to someone

  6 comments for “Relying on Fake German Strength

  1. Jun 16, 2012 at 2:13 am

    Hi Wolf,

    My personal feeling is that Germany will come out fine. As for the rest of them your assessment that it will all come to a head very soon is on the money. The noise about a 'united' effort is all bluff and bluster. How many times have we heard all that before?

    Markets have rallied on the expectation of QE3. Bad news spurred the buying and we also have the presumption that Germany will blink. I doubt that will happen.

  2. watchingthesuckinngmachine
    Jun 16, 2012 at 12:23 pm

    Again, nice try.

    But the constant lying propaganda is too strong of the bankers and their allies, the PIIGS, who are expecting money for free is too strong.

    Germany has long been ripe for plundering

    btw, nothing new there

  3. ziggy
    Jun 16, 2012 at 3:55 pm

    The Germans are a logical people.

    Since the strategy of resuscitating its indebted southern European neighbors is looking futile, they must make sure their other trade partner (the China/US combined economy) stays afloat. China has done this for the US with great success for decades.

    Logically then, Germany must do the following:

    Sell their European assets without disturbing the system. There is only one possible buyer- the ECB.
    Buy US equities. This props up the US, and in turn, China. Keep it in balance as follows:

    US FED lends $ to ECB.
    ECB trades $ to Germany for Euro's.
    Germany sells worthless Euro assets (bonds of other euro countries and banks) to ECB,
    Germany buys American assets.
    American stock market goes up, America gets to buy more Chinese stuff.
    China gets to buy more German stuff.
    Spain/Italy get to decay slowly, enough time is bought to net out the tangled mess of the European debt relationships.
    Everyone goes home happy.
    Eventually a cleaner exit from the Euro is possible for Germany.

  4. Wolf Richter
    Jun 16, 2012 at 10:54 pm

    Ziggy – do I smell the picante flavor of irony in your words?

  5. ziggy
    Jun 17, 2012 at 2:11 pm

    Yes… flavor of the decade, I think.

  6. Jun 19, 2012 at 2:31 am

    I love all the talk from the G20 leaders about the need to work together, when in reality they care about nothing other than their own re-election.

    This is all about not going down in history as the leader that caused the Euro to split. Merket, Hollande, etc… they all know what needs to happen, but no one wants to be remembered as the one that pulled the trigger (which of course would totally be misrepresent the truth, but we have all seen the way the Great Depression has been used by Keynesians to push their idiotic ideas).

    p.s. I cant wait for Germany v Greece at the Euro 2012 tournament. I hope the GErmans withdraw their bailout two hours before game time, just to add a little more spice to the match

Comments are closed.