Rescue of Italy’s Monte dei Paschi Gets ‘Dark’ & ‘Complicated’

A Gargantuan Crime Scene

By Don Quijones, Spain & Mexico, editor at WOLF STREET.

Shares of Monte dei Paschi di Siena, the world’s oldest bank and by now the world’s most famous penny stock, trade at €0.18. Things have gotten so bad that Italy’s financial markets regulator Consob extended the deadline and widened the scope of its ban on short selling of the bank’s shares. The restrictions were initially introduced on July 7 just after the bank’s shares had crashed 20% in one day. Since then they have shed a further 45%.

Doubts continue to mount over the chances of success for the bank’s latest rescue program, its third since the Global Financial Crisis began. “The situation has got more complicated,” reported Il Corriere della Sera, one of Italy’s most influential newspapers. It’s also apparently quite “dark” — as in sinister.

A Dark, Gargantuan Crime Scene

“For weeks, MPS has been in the center of dark, worrying maneuvers,” said Azione Mps, an association of the bank’s retail shareholders. If the worst comes to the worst, the institution they’re invested in will either be bailed-in, resulting in a complete loss of their already basically worthless investment, and/or bailed-out by either Italy’s government or the ECB, in the process massively diluting the value of their already basically worthless shares.

Nonetheless, “dark” is an interesting turn of phrase, especially given that the Italian bank’s latest desperate bid to save its derriere without outright state intervention is being led by America’s most corrupt financial institution (according to Forbes), JP Morgan Chase. Also, in recent days MPS’ head offices, fittingly housed within a restored ancient fortress, have been transformed into a gargantuan crime scene after a Milan court ordered MPS, Nomura and Deutsche Bank to stand trial for a string of alleged financial crimes, including crimes that the Bank of Italy, under Mario Draghi’s tutelage, apparently knew about yet sat on its hands.

The court also indicted 13 former and current managers from the three banks over the case, with prosecutors alleging they had used complex derivatives trades to conceal losses at MPS, in much the same way that Goldman Sachs helped the Greek government to conceal its mountain of excess debt with complex derivatives. [Interestingly, MPS also had a derivatives contract with JP Morgan Chase — the 2006 “Nota Italia” trade — though nothing incriminating has surfaced].

Just as in Greece, MPS’ cleverly concealed debt bomb has had explosive consequences, especially when combined with the bank’s over €40 billion of non-performing loans. Things have gotten so serious that on Monday Italy’s Minister of Economy, Pier Carlo Padoan, called a closed door meeting with the leading figures of the country’s banking sector, including the Bank of Italy’s governor, Vincenzo Visco. Allegedly under discussion was not just the fate of MPS but also of other smaller struggling Italian banks such as Banca Marche, Etruria, Carife and CariChieti.

“Little More Than a Handshake”

But it’s MPS’ slow-motion collapse that is keeping senior members of Italy’s government and banking institutions awake at night. As we warned a couple of weeks ago, the chances of JP Morgan’s rescue plan actually working were razor slim. It essentially involves raising €5 billion in fresh capital for a bank whose market cap has shrunk so much that it is now worth just one-tenth of that amount, and what’s more from investors who have already lost (squandered) billions of euros in two previous cash calls.

“The problem is that raising the funds (for MPS) is proving to be a very difficult challenge — much more so than was presented in the optimistic rescue plan,” said Nicola Borri, an analyst at Luiss de Roma University.

For the moment that plan is going sideways. As Federico de Bortoli, the former director of ‘Il Corriere’, put it, nothing of any substance has been signed apart from a pre-underwriting agreement, which amounts to “little more than a handshake.” In other words, there’s no commitment. And if there’s no commitment, there’s still no deal.

Deal or no deal, JP Morgan Chase and its Italian co-underwriter Mediobanca can be expected to walk away with their fees in tact. They’re likely to add up to a fair amount of money: as much as €250 million in underwriting fees, plus an extra €300 million or so for setting up a €6-billion syndicated bridge loan.

For JP Morgan Chase, that’s just the beginning of the windfalls it is likely to accrue from Italy’s burgeoning financial crisis. The bank, whose CEO Jamie Dimon seemingly enjoys cozy ties with Italy’s premier Matteo Renzi and who was recently been anointed Italy’s “unlikely savior” by the Wall Street Journal, also picked up a little something from helping Banca Popolare di Bari SCpA offload half a billion euros of bad loans from its balance sheet. It is also helping Italy’s largest bank, UniCredit SpA, drum up at least €8 billion ($8.9 billion) of capital.

The more perilous Italy’s financial situation gets, the more money there is to be made for America’s “most corrupt bank.” As the old adage goes, where there is crisis, there’s always opportunity. And if you can help create the conditions that lead to crisis — as banks like JP Morgan Chase and Goldman Sachs have done throughout this fledgling century — you can be in a perfect position to reap the opportunities. By Don Quijones, Raging Bull-Shit.

It just doesn’t let up with the banks. Read…  Stealth Bailout of 2 Franken-Banks Now Happening in Spain

Enjoy reading WOLF STREET and want to support it? You can donate. I appreciate it immensely. Click on the beer and iced-tea mug to find out how:

Would you like to be notified via email when WOLF STREET publishes a new article? Sign up here.

  12 comments for “Rescue of Italy’s Monte dei Paschi Gets ‘Dark’ & ‘Complicated’

  1. George McDuffee says:

    Madoff was an amateur.

    • Petunia says:

      Madoff was stupid. He could have blamed the financial crisis for the losses and nobody would have ever known.

  2. Paul Easton says:

    It may well be that Chase is America’s most corrupt bank in their high level wheeling and dealing, but as a retail customer I have found them delightful. About 6 years ago I had a medical problem that left me unable to function for 3 years. When I came back to the world I found they had forgiven the 12K I owed on my Chase Visa Card. Since then I opened another account and everything has been very smooth and the people I deal with have been very nice.

    OTOH in a fit of idealism a couple of years ago I opened an account at the Amalgamated Bank of NY, “The Labor Bank”. There were no branches anywhere near me so I planned to use it online, but I never got around to it and forgot about it. Then some months ago they called and said I owed them 180. I never heard of such a thing so I wanted to know why. I am no longer living in NYC. I phoned 3 times asking to talk to an officer and was left hanging half an hour after which I gave up. I emailed them and got no answer. So the next time they called I said I wouldn’t pay. The man said ok and hung up immediately. I haven’t checked it yet but I suspect I am on the banking blacklist, which makes it impossible to open a new account and totally ruins your credit. Next step is to go to CFPB. So much for “progressive bankers”.

    • walter map says:

      “I found they had forgiven the 12K I owed on my Chase Visa Card.”

      Never mind. I get it.

  3. Humpty Dumpty says:

    This article highlights the way mega banks have found a way to cannibalize their starving brethren, much like rats will do. And, indeed many such feeding ‘opportunities’ now exist in the world thanks in no small part to the courage of central banks over the last decade. As we watch them, knowing that eventually they must swallow their tails, the question remains exactly what leftovers there might be for insects like us.

  4. nhz says:

    “Deal or no deal, JP Morgan Chase and its Italian co-underwriter Mediobanca can be expected to walk away with their fees in tact. They’re likely to add up to a fair amount of money: as much as €250 million in underwriting fees, plus an extra €300 million or so for setting up a €6-billion syndicated bridge loan.”

    So … they are extracting the last bit of market value that is left in MPS in exchange for some phony promises. Nice business if you can get it. It’s a bit surprising though that Dark Lord Lloyd is not participating this time; maybe he reckons he already made more than enough money by organizing the mayhem in ClubMed?

    • Mel says:

      For €5.5million I’ll let them use my recovery plan, that involves selling cookies in the street.

  5. Dan Romig says:

    It appears that MPS has engaged in “dark, working maneuverers”, and is insolvent. Can’t this bank be allowed to go under, where it belongs?

    Why should any investment be made towards a corporation run by criminals without removing the criminals first at least?

    • walter map says:

      “Why should any investment be made towards a corporation run by criminals without removing the criminals first at least?”

      Who’s going to run the corporation if you jail all the criminals? And who’s going to bail them out?

      The world’s economies are hostage to racketeering operations, which economies will continue to lurch from one crisis to the next until you figure out how to get rid of the racketeers. And they do everything to make sure you can’t. They run the show.

      Stunning Crimes of the Big Banks: Worse than Your Wildest Imagination

      Economic collapses, war crimes, genocide. Ugly ugly ugly.

      All very profitable.

  6. Tom Kauser says:

    90% of derivatives are side bets on interest rates and rate hedging strategy’s
    10% of derivatives are time capsules inside circular cans?
    Niagara falls slowly i turn…….

  7. Tom Kauser says:

    AIG “walked away bow legged” with its Fee’s

Comments are closed.