The Banking Crisis in Spain is Back

The shares of Banco Popular got crushed.

By Don Quijones, Spain & Mexico, editor at WOLF STREET.

After three years of relative calm and one month before yet another round of do-or-die general elections, the words “banking” and “crisis” are back on the front pages of Spain’s newspapers. Despite the untold billions of euros of public funds lavished on “cleaning up” their balance sheets and the roughly €240 billion of provisions booked against bad debt since December 2007, the banks are just as weak and disaster-prone as they were four years ago.

Francisco González, the President of Spain’s second biggest financial institution, BBVA, was the first to raise the alarm, warning a few days ago that the ECB’s negative interest rate policy “is killing” European banks.

Now, it seems González’s prophecy is already coming true.

Spain’s sixth largest financial institution, Banco Popular, on Wednesday evening announced that it was urgently seeking to raise €2.5 billion in capital in order to shore up its finances. The news took many of the firm’s investors by surprise given that just a month ago the bank’s CEO Francisco Gomez had breezily reported that the bank had a very comfortable core capital level above the regulatory minimum and “one of the best” leverage ratios in the sector.

The market’s response to the latest news was emphatic. The bank’s shares plunged 25% Thursday morning. There was not even the barest flicker of a recovery on Thursday afternoon. On Friday, the stock dropped another 8.2%, to close at €1.59 per share, its lowest in 26 years. Over the three days, the stock plummeted 32%.

For the bank’s shareholders, it’s the second time this has happened in the last four years. In 2012, the bank’s management — virtually man-for-man the same management team as today — pulled the exact same stunt in an effort to stabilize the bank’s finances. The slogan the bank chose to sell that capital increase was “Our Past and Our Present Guarantee Our Future.”

The guarantee didn’t last very long. Now, Banco Popular has laundry list of problems:

  1. Recent financial regulations raising the minimum capital buffer have had the effect of tightening the operating margins of many institutions, including Banco Popular.
  2. The ECB’s “magic people” have coaxed interest rates in Europe to the lowest point in human history. Already tight margins have got even tighter. As Gónzalez says, it’s “killing” banks.
  3. According to an auspiciously timed report from JP Morgan Chase, Banco Popular would need to provision up to €6.7 billion to comply with the new accounting rules, a lot more than the €2.5 billion it hopes to raise. And Popular has already seen €1.3 billion wiped off its share value in the last two days’ trading alone.
  4. Despite the so-called cleansing of Spain’s financial sector, Banco Popular’s books are still jam-packed with toxic junk, primarily consisting of non-performing loans (NPLs) connected to the real estate sector. At a staggering 12.6%, the bank’s bad debt ratio is the highest of any Spanish bank; 26% of its total loan portfolio is concentrated in the real estate and construction sectors.
  5. Popular’s current coverage ratio, or its ability to absorb potential losses from bad loans, is 39%, far lower than the Spanish bank average of around 56%.
  6. Popular is heavily implicated in Spain’s floor clause scandal. If upcoming lawsuits go against the banks, Popular will have to shell out some €700 million in customer reimbursements. The bank has warned that it could end up booking losses worth €2 billion in 2016.

Whether it gets its second €2.5 billion capital expansion or not, Banco Popular problems are likely to get worse. And its management should be beyond salvation, for ruthlessly hanging shareholders out to dry not once, but twice.

“There are already clear signs of ethical misconduct when Popular announced positive-sounding results three months ago,” says independent analyst Alberto Iturralde. “The bank gave good news back then because its shares were about to break through key resistance levels. And they just made the latest announcement at a most propitious time, with the shares back at €2.20 a piece,… and without giving [investors] any time to get out.”

Instead of facing the ire of investors, the bank’s senior management was in London courting global investment funds at the Savoy Hotel. Popular was able to find 14 international banks willing to underwrite its capital expansion. In effect, they guarantee they will find all the investors Popular needs, despite the bank’s track record of capital destruction.

At the top of the list is UBS, which has committed to underwrite 22% of the new shares, followed by everyone’s favorite financial cephalopod, Goldman Sachs (16.4%), Spain’s two biggest banks, Santander and the no-longer too-big-to-fail BBVA (16.4% between them), Barclays, Citi, Deutsche Bank, Morgan Stanley, HSBC, Credit Suisse, Société Génerale and Nomura. The two boutique firms Fidentiis and N+1 will also participate in the launch as co-managers. They can already taste the juicy fees and invaluable insider information.

As Bloomberg notes, Popular has problems that are fairly common across banks in the euro area: “questionable balance-sheet strength, a rough revenue outlook, and weak governance.”

It is certainly not the only Spanish bank to still have massive exposure to Spain’s troubled real estate sector. The last thing Spain — and by extension, Europe’s — financial sector needs is for people to begin questioning just how fixed these banks really are, especially mere weeks before make-or-break elections in Spain and the mother of all referendums in the UK. By Don Quijones, Raging Bull-Shit

“Europe is caught in a trap,” said BBVA’s Executive Chairman González. The ECB is trying to boost growth potential, but it’s these “negative interest rates which are killing us.” Read…   NIRP is “Killing Us,” Wheezes Spain’s Second Biggest Bank

Enjoy reading WOLF STREET and want to support it? You can donate. I appreciate it immensely. Click on the beer and iced-tea mug to find out how:

Would you like to be notified via email when WOLF STREET publishes a new article? Sign up here.

  11 comments for “The Banking Crisis in Spain is Back

  1. michael says:

    The banking crisis never ended. I would suggest the ECB’s goal is not growth, as negative interest rates will only cause money to move towards any entity providing positive interest rates. That is not going to generate any growth in the ECB. This is either a pro bono act in support of the dollar or the ECB is filled with fools. Or perhaps both.

  2. Petunia says:

    I remember Banco Popular being a big bank in Puerto Rico. Has the debt crisis in Puerto Rico become part of Banco Popular’s problem as well? If it has, I expect they will benefit from the impending bailout from Washington.

  3. Chip Javert says:

    General question about Euro banks: how much lipstick can you put on a pig before it can’t even walk?

    My favorite Euro bank story is the “stress test”, which almost everybody passes…then a few months later…POW!…the crap hits the fan.

    US banks are somewhat better, with the exception of BofA and Citi; these guys so abused the public trust that they still haven’t “recovered”. I vote for selling their branches to regional banks, shutting down everything else, and laying off 30,000-50,000 of the worst bank managers on the planet.

  4. There are no real returns anywhere in the European Union (or anywhere else for that matter) this leaves the lenders borrowing from each other hoping nobody notices.

    What a way to run a railroad …

  5. Brian Richards says:

    Hi Petunia,
    The main office of Banco Popular is just a 1/2 block away from my house in Ponce, PR. I attempted to open up an account with them in 2013 and I was turned down. Banco Santander, a few steps away welcomed my business. Maybe Banco Popular is badly run. Still, I wonder if there are ANY safe banks anymore.

  6. NotSoSure says:

    Wake me up when there is a real crisis.

    • CV5 says:

      The real crisis will occur when capital controls come to your bank and branch lol.

      • NotSoSure says:

        Yesterday I went to deposit 400 dollars in cash in person because I forgot my ATM pin. It took the longest time for the person to accept my cash. I was telling them that I wasn’t doing any money laundering.

        • CV5 says:

          I know of people who all pulling all of their cash out the wretched ponzi before the inevitable.

        • Cash Poor says:


          Why would you bring up money-laundering with the bank? Aren’t you just feeding them ideas by doing so?

          I irregularly, maybe a couple of times a month deposit $1,000, $2,000 or $5,000 or so of cash, give or take a hundred here or there in my bank account after certain friends pay up.

          Never had a single question asked about these larger than usual amounts of cash.

  7. Brian says:

    No surprise other banks backing the “rescue” as they all know it will only take a cascading bank failure series and its all over for them. A banking license is very valuable as you get to create money (20 times what they have from depositors and investors) as secured loans for free and charge interest on those and they show up on their balance sheet as assets. Depositors funds are unsecured of course….And if they fail, taxpayers have to fund their losses via more taxes or haircuts on their deposits. Isn’t it a great business model, and surprisingly, legal!

Comments are closed.