Now it’s confirmed, it wasn’t for PPP-loan fraud.
By Wolf Richter for WOLF STREET.
One of the many economic mindblowers during the pandemic was the spike in new business formations, based on applications for Employer Identification Numbers (EIN) with the IRS. They exploded in July last year, then zigzagged up and down, and in May, hit the second highest ever. Throughout, there were suspicions that business applications were spiking because fraudsters were creating businesses to obtain PPP loans – though an EIN wasn’t even required for PPP loans. The PPP ended in May. And today, we got the business applications for June.
In June, 448,533 EIN applications were filed with the IRS, the seventh highest in the data and up 56% from June 2019, according to the Census Bureau today. In the first half of this year, 2.81 million such applications were filed, up by 61% from the first half in 2019.
This may shed more light on the phenomenon that people, flush with stimulus money and income from unemployment compensation and stock market gains, are striking out on their own – which would be a great thing. And it may also shed some light from a different angle on the unemployment situation and the difficulties companies have in hiring workers.
The EIN is for businesses what the Social Security number is for individual taxpayers. Excluded are EIN applications that are unrelated to typical business formations, such for tax liens, estates, trusts, etc.
Most startups will create only a job for the owner and maybe a few others. And that’s great. Those types of small potentially exciting businesses – such as the WOLF STREET media mogul empire before you – hire all kinds of other businesses or people on a contract basis, from accounting to IT support. They just don’t add many employees. But there are other startups that do have the potential to create lots of jobs, though their number is a lot smaller.
The potential job creators.
Based on the information in the EIN application, the Census Bureau identified businesses that have a “high propensity” of creating a significant payroll – the “High-Propensity Business Applications” (HBA).
In June, 152,272 businesses filed applications deemed to be HBAs, up 39% from June 2019. In the first half this year, 955,121 businesses filed these types of applications, up 45% from the first half in 2019:
The real potential job creators.
Within the group of HBAs is the subgroup of “Business Applications with Planned Wages” (WBA) by businesses that already have a planned date for paying wages. They have funding, they have hired people, and they’re ready to pay wages. They’re deemed to be most likely to grow their payroll and become significant employers.
In June, 52,325 WBAs were filed, up 31% from June 2019. In the first half this year, 329,414 of these types of business applications were filed, up 36% from the first half in 2019.
But even that spike in July last year was still down about 30% from the levels that prevailed before the Financial Crisis. In the years between 2013 and 2019, the number of WBAs was down by nearly half from the pre-Financial Crisis levels. These real potential job creators, despite the surge, have remained scarce since the Financial Crisis:
Mostly businesses with a low propensity to create jobs.
Total business applications minus the “High-Propensity Business Applications” leaves us with the remainder, what I term the low-propensity business applications (red line in the chart below). They might only employ the owner and someday a few other people, but many remain one-man or one-woman shows.
And that’s a great way to go. But the failure rates are very high. In many cases, the owners quietly throw in the towel, shut down the business whose losses they’d funded on their credit cards, and either start up another business or get a job.
Applications for these types of businesses began to surged during the Financial Crisis and continued to rise – even as the other types of applications declined or remained flat – and nearly doubled from the year 2007 (1.1 million) to the year 2019 (2.2 million). And then came the huge spike in mid-2020, when millions of people got laid off and were flush with cash to strike out and start something new.
By contrast, in June, the HBAs had barely recovered to 2007 levels, after years of drought (purple line); and the WBAs never hit those 2007 levels again, not even during the spike last July (green line):
What types of businesses are they?
Retail trade dominates. Brick-and-mortar retail businesses have long been under siege from ecommerce, and then took a brutal beating during the pandemic. Over the years, tens of thousands of stores were shuttered, from Sears stores down to small shops, and numerous malls turned into zombie malls. And the pandemic accelerated that process. Yet, entrepreneurs never gave up on retail, they just did it online. They can run an operation out of their garage and ride the historic boom of ecommerce during the pandemic.
In June, 81,351 businesses filed applications listing the NAICS (North American Industry Classification System) code for retail trade businesses. This was up by 86% from June 2019.
In the first half, 543,468 such applications were filed, up by 110% from the first half in 2019. Nothing else comes close (red line below).
Retail trade business applications used to run roughly on the same level as, or below, professional services applications (green line) but during the Pandemic just exploded higher.
The top seven industries, by number of business applications in June, and the % increase from June 2019:
- Retail (red): 81,352, +87%.
- Professionally services (light blue): 52,087, +37%.
- Transportation & warehousing (green): 41,812, +110% related to the delivery requirements of the ecommerce boom.
- Construction (black): 39,709, +30%.
- Administration and support (yellow): 32,624, +62%
- Accommodation and food services (gray): 26,783, +73%
- Health Care and Social Assistance (brown): 25,445, +31%
Eager entrepreneurs in the waiting…
A recent LendingTree survey found that 70% of Americans would rather work for themselves, than for someone else. Among millennials, 77% would rather work for themselves. That is a huge pool of people that might someday be dreaming about starting their own business.
And 37% of millennials thought about starting their own business last year, followed by Gen Zers (30%) and Gen Xers (25%). Boomers not so much (7%).
The survey also found that 82% of these prospective entrepreneurs would take a pay cut for a year as they worked on their business.
The stimulus and extra unemployment payments during the pandemic may have made it possible for entrepreneurs to get their ducks all lined up in a row, and put their businesses together, while still getting some cash flow to cover their household expenses. And those creative juices are a good thing.
Enjoy reading WOLF STREET and want to support it? You can donate. I appreciate it immensely. Click on the beer and iced-tea mug to find out how:
Would you like to be notified via email when WOLF STREET publishes a new article? Sign up here.