Is Catalonia About to Go All In?

An extremely high-stakes game of political poker, not just for Catalonia and Spain but for Europe.

By Don Quijones, Spain & Mexico, editor at WOLF STREET.

For a nation that doesn’t officially exist, Catalonia sure knows how to throw a national-day party. September 11, approximately 1.4 million people filled the streets of the region’s capital, Barcelona (urban population: 1.6 million), to commemorate La Diada, the fateful day 301 years ago when Catalonia was defeated during the War of the Spanish Succession.

This year’s event was widely praised, even among some unionists, for its near flawless organization, and once again the atmosphere was one of peaceful joviality, resolute defiance and collective hope.

Here are some photos I took in the evening after the march, at an event held in our neighborhood. In the first one, you can see a Castellers (human tower):

QD2015-09-12 Catalonia-independence-Castellers

In the second one you can see the “Arc de Triomf” in the background, with a massive independence flag swaying in the breeze:

DQ-2015-09-12-Catalonia-independence

But now the festivities are over, and the really hard work of nation building begins. Hope, catchy slogans, and huge demonstrations alone are not enough to create a new nation.

Institutions of State

A nation needs a viable economy, which Catalonia already has; it needs international acceptance and recognition, which could be a much higher mountain to climb, especially given the threat posed by separatist movements in other European countries (France, Italy, the UK, Belgium); and it needs the basic organs and institutions of state. According to Catalonia’s premier, Artur Mas, these are now under development.

“One crucial task for the next government will be to create the state structures that will succeed those of the Spanish state: the tax authority, for example, which we have already worked on for the past year and a half, or social security or the central bank,” he told the Financial Times.

In other words, it seems that Catalonia’s pro-independence coalition is now moving inexorably from the realm of fanciful words to the realm of determined action. Mas and his colleagues believe that for Catalonia to be a sovereign nation state, it needs its own central bank – which is probably true – but preferably one affiliated with the European Central Bank (ECB).

This is perhaps the ultimate paradox: Catalan separatists want to split from Madrid in the name of self-determination but most of them want to remain part of both the EU and the Eurozone, despite the obvious sacrifice this would require in terms of economic and political sovereignty. [As an aside, it’s worth noting that Mas’s party is also strongly in favor of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) which, together with similar trade treaties like TPP and TiSA, poses arguably the biggest threat to national sovereignty in today’s world).

The EU may have other ideas, anyway. The chairman of the European Central Bank (ECB), Mario Draghi, has already roundly rejected a petition to turn the Catalan Institute of Finance into an ECB-affiliated central bank. And according to the governor of the Bank of Spain, Luis María Linde, if Catalonia were to declare independence, Catalan-based banks such as CaixaBank, Banco Sabadell and Catalunya Banc would face serious problems and could even go under:

There is no possibility in a systematic and significant way for a bank from a territory that is not a member of the European Union to fund itself from the ECB through its subsidiaries in territories which are EU members. The ECB only lends against a guarantee issued by a borrower that is a member of the European economic area.

High-Stakes Political Poker

Whether Linde is right only time can tell. After all, there is no historic precedence for what could be about to happen.

Even so, prophecies of doom and gloom no longer have the impact they may once have had on the collective mood or mind of Catalonia’s pro-independence movement. Nor for that matter do stern admonishments from European leaders like Angela Merkel or David Cameron that a newly independent Catalonia would not automatically qualify for EU membership, as many pro-independence politicians such as Mas constantly claim. In Catalonia, just as in Madrid, emotion and gut feeling, rather than logic or reason, is now firmly in the driving seat.

That’s why just about anything could happen in the coming weeks and months. If the common electoral list of pro-independence parties wins a majority of seats in this month’s regional elections – a likely outcome if recent polls are anything to go by – it has vowed to establish a government lasting no longer than 18 months to put in place the institutional frameworks needed to lead the region toward independence. That includes a Catalan military (affiliated with NATO, of course).

This would be Catalonia’s all-in moment in what is fast becoming an extremely high-stakes game of political poker – and not just for Catalonia and Spain but for the whole of Europe.

As the FT notes, the idea of building a state within the Spanish state is sure to infuriate Madrid, which has already threatened to reestablish centralized control of Spain’s north-eastern region as well as send in tanks and/or even charge pro-independence politicians with sedition (punishable with up to 15 years in prison) – hardly the sort of actions that are likely to diffuse an already explosive situation. By Don Quijones, Raging Bull-Shit.

Even chief financial alchemist Draghi is unable to prevent gravity from taking hold. Read… Investors Get Jittery As Spain Enters Whole New World of Pain

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on RedditPrint this pageEmail this to someone

  5 comments for “Is Catalonia About to Go All In?

  1. VarAway
    Sep 12, 2015 at 7:53 pm

    Good article, but I have one remark..
    ” ECB Mario Draghi roundly rejected…..”
    But our Mario is having no problem giving those (unsecured) loans to our
    good friends in Greece?
    I would rate the IOY’s from a Catalan Government much better/higher than
    the so called ” secured ” loans to the Greeks.

  2. NotSoSure
    Sep 12, 2015 at 11:45 pm

    Will turn out to be another non-event. If you want to separate, why wait for some date? And even if the vote passes, the powers that be have learned the lesson of Greece i.e. you can still vote for what you think you want, and then get a worse outcome.

    As usual, lemmings end up with a score of zero and they deserve it.

  3. Albizu
    Sep 13, 2015 at 9:22 am

    It won’t happen: Mas himself said that ‘there is no such thing as independence within the EU’.

    Just riding the tiger and trying to stay in power and cut a deal.

    But the Catalans are at least brighter than the Basques: no killings.

    That’s something in so intellectually backward and blood-stained a nation as Spain.

    My ancestors fought for the old Kings of that region (Aragonese actually), so when being irrational, I rather like all of this.

    But it’s a farce.

  4. Robert
    Sep 13, 2015 at 10:05 am

    ” Mas and his colleagues believe that for Catalonia to be a sovereign nation state, it needs its own central bank – which is probably true.” If Catalonia wishes to make a break with the past, it would be healthy to start off without a tapeworm in its system, which is what a central bank is. If they are determined to live within their means, all they need is a functioning Treasury Department. Central banks, operating hand-in-glove with corrupt governments are only able to inflate currencies to the extent that new debt can be created- and debt is the reason Europe is tottering.

  5. Petunia
    Sep 13, 2015 at 10:23 am

    Catalan independence is a farce and it has been ongoing for too long. As we have already seen nobody will be leaving the EU. In an already dangerous world they need to get serious about their place in it. If they expended the energy they waste on this useless endeavor on taking over Madrid, Spain would be the powerhouse of Europe.

Comments are closed.