Home prices in Canada’s two largest metro areas have been red-hot for years. In May, the average selling price for all types of homes in the Greater Toronto Area jumped 11% from a year ago to C$649,600 on a 6% increase in sales. In Greater Vancouver, the composite benchmark price for all homes rose 9.4% to C$684,400 on a 23% increase in sales.
But these overall price changes paper over what’s happening with detached homes, whose prices soared 14% to C$1,104,900 in Vancouver and 18% to C$1,115,120 in Toronto.
Already last summer, Fitch fretted about overvaluation in housing and the high debt burden relative to disposable income of Canadian households. At about the same time, seven in ten mortgage lenders expressed concerns in a poll by FICO that home prices were in a “bubble” that could burst any time. Last October, the Bank of Canada thought that the housing bubble could threaten Canada’s financial stability.
This January, Deutsche Bank estimated that homes in Canada were 63% overvalued. In March, the IMF warned that high household debt levels and the “overheated housing market” are two risks it would “need to keep an eye on.” In April, the Economist determined that home prices in Canada were overvalued by 35% when compared to incomes, and 89% when compared to rents.
Now hedge funds are trying to engineer ways to short the Canadian housing market one way or the other, because surely this would be another “short of a lifetime.”
Maybe they’re right: beyond Toronto and Vancouver, the housing market is already drifting lower.
So it’s about time someone in the industry fights back and explains to those hedge funds that this market isn’t about to pop. But gosh, calling first-time homebuyers “plankton” in the “food chain” of the housing market that feeds “big wales and sharks?”
That’s what Stuart Levings, CEO of Canada’s largest mortgage insurer, Genworth MI Canada, told Bloomberg in an interview:
”We look at the housing market like a food chain. The first-time homebuyers are really the plankton. And if you don’t have plankton in the ocean, you’re going to eventually starve out even the big whales and the sharks. You need that first time homebuyer to buy that home so the next person can move out to buy their own home.”
And there was plenty of this plankton, namely millennials and about 250,000 immigrants per year who’re buying their first property, he said.
“There is strong demand in this country and there will always be,” Levings said. “Why? Simply because of our immigration policy. We bring in first-time buyer pipelines through our immigration policy. They are great future first-time homebuyers that become plankton.”
The federal government put in place some rules to tamp down on the housing bubble, including shorter amortizations and higher down payments, which has kept the subprime elements out of the market, he said, with average credit scores of Genworth customers being a high 737 points.
“We’ve squeezed the first-time homebuyers down into a small group who are qualified, good-quality borrowers,” he said. But the government should avoid tightening the rules further to avoid squeezing first-time buyers out entirely and poisoning the food chain.
And there won’t be a major correction in home prices, he said. That would require forced sales, the way it happened in the US during the housing bust, where owners, when they realized their homes were worth less than the mortgage, simply walked away.
That won’t happen in Canada. Mortgages are full-recourse, he said, and borrowers are personally liable. “We don’t see the herd mentality in Canada that we’ve seen in other markets,” he said. “Even in the 2008 crisis in Alberta, where prices dropped 25%, we did not see people walking away.”
That too may be a false reassurance. In the US, only about a dozen states are non-recourse. The rest of the states are like Canada. But trying to recover any significant amount of money from struggling borrowers who were upside-down in their mortgages turned out to be impossible. And investors owned their properties in LLCs so that the individual was protected by the corporate shield. Some of the hardest hit states, such as Nevada and Florida, were full-recourse. So if it can happen in the US, it can happen in Canada.
And besides, low interest rates keep the plankton alive, he said.
Housing is already in trouble in some cities, but it’s no big deal. In Calgary, the epicenter of the Canadian oil bust, the oil industry has cut thousands of jobs, home sales have dropped 28% in April from a year ago, and prices 1.5% since November, he said. But reality on the ground wasn’t that bad, he said. Many companies have opted to cut their employees’ pay rather than laying them off. So they continue to pay their mortgages.
The new rules have pushed subprime borrowers into the shadow banking sector of non-federally regulated lenders, which according to some estimates, provide about 10% of all mortgages. But Levings disagreed. That sector accounts for only 2% to 3%, he said. Subprime is “like the flea on the tail of the dog,” too minuscule to matter.
Levings, CEO of a mortgage insurer, is talking his book. He wants to persuade US hedge funds that the Canadian housing bubble will never blow up. There’s simply too much “plankton” in the water. It keeps the “food chain” healthy and offers ample nourishment for the “big wales and sharks.” And shorting the Canadian housing bubble is useless.
Denial works. But here’s the irony: even “second-time homebuyers” can’t afford to buy a home without a lot of help from mom and dad. Read…. Canada’s Magnificent Housing Bubble Goes Nuts, Cracks
Enjoy reading WOLF STREET and want to support it? You can donate. I appreciate it immensely. Click on the beer and iced-tea mug to find out how:
Would you like to be notified via email when WOLF STREET publishes a new article? Sign up here.