My Wine! What Just Happened on in the Streets of Mendoza?

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Share on RedditPrint this pageEmail this to someone

By Bianca Fernet, ArgentinaBianca@bubblear.com

Living in Argentina, you learn to get by without certain luxuries. It’s a mixed bag. A balancing act if you will. As a foreigner does in any strange land, you find yourself giving up some benefits of modernity – like assured access to tampons – in order to enjoy other of pleasures.

But yesterday things may have tipped the balance for quite a few people. In the city of Mendoza, the continent’s wine capital, a group consisting of over 5,000 growers, winemakers, and vineyard employees packed the city streets with tractors, poured wine on the steps of city hall, and are chanting and sign-waving with the aim of stopping the annual Fiesta de la Vendimia.

The Fiesta de la Vendimia is the harvest festival, a world-renowned highly-attended event. It attracts global attention, spendy tourists, and money to the province. This is of great importance and benefit to both the local and national government. So why would the actual wine industry participants want to stop a festival celebrating wine?

The protest is in response to the government’s failure to act on promises to financially assist the struggling sector. Earlier in the week both national and local politicians made promises to provide the sector with financial aid to assist with this year’s harvest, due in a matter of weeks. President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner committed provide ARS $50 million from the Mendoza Fiduciary Trust to buy up excess stock and stop the price slide that has resulted from a steep fall in exports.  What she plans to do with that much wine I do not know. But shocking no one, the government has not come through and assisted members of the community  hit hard by the affects of the country’s self-inflicted crisis.

The Argentine wine sector has been hit by falling exports, high inflation, tight credit, and an unfavorable exchange rate. In 2013 exports fell for the first time in a decade from US $918 million to US $866 million. 2014 estimates come in at US $823 million. Costs have increased for industry essentials including bottles and barrels, and the difference between the parallel and official exchange rate has exacerbated the problem.

To put some numbers on it, imagine a wine producer exports 100 bottles of wine for US $15 dollars apiece, net of taxes. Overseas their earnings would amount to US $1500. But laws force these exporters to bring these earnings back at the official rate of ARS $8.50 per USD, so that US $1,500 becomes ARS $12,750 compared to  the ARS $20,250 these dollars have on the parallel market. Quite the loss in purchasing power.

A recent article that I suspect to be working on old information reports that in the past four years, grape prices have risen 10-15 percent whereas production costs have gone up by 80 percent.  A liter of basic red wine sells for ARS $2.64 but costs ARS $4.50 to produce. I’ve never seen even the swilliest of swill cost anywhere near that little, but I assume that with inflation the idea still stands. These guys are making less than their production costs selling in the local market, local prices don’t rise fast enough to compensate for cost increases, and exporting requires scale that small producers just don’t have.

While a glut in the wine market sounds like a fun time, it’s actually hurting producers to the point where they don’t have the money to harvest the grapes required for next year’s production. And where the government evidently has money for an international wine hooplah, they haven’t ponied up the funds promised to assist with the harvest.

What the government should do is fix the economy’s endemic problems that cause Argentine local purchasing power to be so low, ease administrative constraints thus allowing more producers to export at higher prices, and fix the ridiculous parallel currency problem so exporters could bring returns back to the country and reinvest in what should be one of the nation’s leading industries.

Argentine wine producers should be leading the world, not be forced to drive tractors in circles through the city and pour wine on steps. The government being required to bail out the wine industry, of all things, is a perfect example of the ripple effect of short-sighted, self-serving populist policies that hurt industries and the people they employ. In Argentina’s wine industry, that’s over 400,000 people. Awesome.

So while typically I’d take in this government’s latest economic folly by putting up my feet and enjoying a nice glass of malbec, the situation of these 400,000 humans has put a sour taste in my mouth. By Bianca Fernet, Argentina, The Bubble.

As of January 1, Argentina actually could pay the hedge-fund “vultures” without going bankrupt. But it won’t. Read…  In 2015, it Boils Down to this: Argentina Will Not Pay Because President Christina Doesn’t Want to

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Share on RedditPrint this pageEmail this to someone

  4 comments for “My Wine! What Just Happened on in the Streets of Mendoza?

  1. Michael Gorback
    Jan 16, 2015 at 7:58 pm

    Bodega Catena Zapata is in danger? Now you have my full attention.

  2. Ray
    Jan 17, 2015 at 9:46 pm

    “So while typically I’d take in this government’s latest economic folly by putting up my feet and enjoying a nice glass of malbec, the situation of these 400,000 humans has put a sour taste in my mouth.”

    I would get out the popcorn and enjoy the comedy of those 400,000 begging the government to fix the problem that they themselves caused by asking government to fix problems. The fact that they are out there protesting is enough proof to me that they are the tragic clowns of the show who have no idea how stupid they are.

    • Jan 18, 2015 at 12:16 am

      Ray, you’re pointing your finger in the wrong direction.

      These are the consequences of a government that ruins the currency, creates a dual exchange rate system with an artificial official exchange rate, and inflicts all sorts of import and export controls along with capital controls on the economy. The government of Argentina has tried very hard to kill what’s left of functional capitalism. As the articles said, give Argentina a decent currency with a market exchange rate, get out of the way, and let these 400,000 people do their jobs. Argentinians know how to make wine and export it. But the government’s idiotic policies are ruining it for everyone.

      • Ray
        Jan 18, 2015 at 12:51 am

        “The government of Argentina has tried very hard to kill what’s left of functional capitalism.” Go and do a survey among those 400,000 and ask them if they want laissez faire capitalism or socialism, then we’ll talk about whether the finger is being pointed in the right place. Where do these 400,000 wine dumping protesters think the money for government help is going to come from?

Comments are closed.